Sunday Chat
Saturday, June 14th, 2014 09:07 pmSalad Server Whitelist Changes
Pause read fanficton on stream!!! And it wasn't even on Salad. Apparently there's fic on wattpad. It's official. The kinky people hang out on wattpad.
More like saturday chat but by the time you see this it'll probs be sunday in some part of the globe. give this 10 mins for nz at least. But who even cares I'm the one who posts this thing and I have lots of things to talk about so sue me.
Not really gonna talk about events in salad or Mindcrack today. Instead, I've got some more general and even a couple of meta things to talk about. So here we go. (Also, happy b-day, Kurt!)
Let's start with the short and sweet stuff. I just want to start off by saying congrats to some of the members who joined between the 150 and 200 member mark as reading some of their fics, I'm starting to see a good amount of improvement in fic quality from people such as
purplesky which is really great. It's good to see people's writing improve and is a good bit of inspiration for some of our newer members and shoes that a bit of effort and practise really can make a difference. :D Keep up the writing
Still on the short side, just a reminder that people properly tag posts. If it's fiction, use the fanficton tag, if it's something else, look in that tag to see what kind of things are posted to that tag before adding that tag. Make sure that when you add the tag, it's spelled and worded exactly as in the sidebar otherwise it won't be added. And on correct tag usage, when tagging Mindcrackers, don't go overboard with the tags. The tags are used to find fics about those people, not people who have a one sentence mention. I recommend keeping it to the main characters in that fic. And if you want to be super helpful with the SFP, no more than 4 character tags. Tagging is good, but don't go overboard. Also make sure you're appropriately adding age-restriction barriers such as nsfw and 18+ where appropriate.
More on the short things, in a recent livestream Seth mentioned that he has recorded sans pants before. Other Mindcrackers have also mentioned this in the past. What are your thoughts on this? Any prompty fic ideas come out of it?I love it but shh I didn't say that okay.
Now onto the meta stuff: Salad Mentions:
In the recent podcast the salad, or more specifically, the mindcrack fanfic site was brought up with promises of linking Sevadus to it after the podcast. As of late, Vechs has also made plenty of salad mentions, and t has been talked about by various mindcrackers a lot more than it used to be. This got me thinking and I wanted to talk about it here.
What do you guys think about the more common mentions of salad by mindcrackers? To some extent they're good in directing more members towards mindcrack fanficton which can be good, but making a bit of a name for ourselves does have other connotations. TBH, some part of me is a little uncomfortable about the salad mentions, especially from people like Vechs who seem to mention it at least every other week or more as of late. I feel like some of that taboo about real person fiction and the main unspoken rule about not showing them the rpf fic is being impeded on and I also kind of wonder what kind of audience those mentions are bringing to salad and wonder if all these mentions may soon start to direct trolls in out direction. It is great that mindcrack is generally so accepting of fanfiction and in some cases, openly encourages it which is a luxury many other fandoms don't have, but I kinda feel like salad is the kind of thing better kept hush-hush about - more of a question whispered between strangers in the dark or exchanged under the quiet of private message. Do you think salad should be openly mentioned? How do hearing those mentions make you feel?
And a continuation of this? At's now becoming more known that mindcrackers and such still read some of the fics on here with some of them such as Aurey and Vechs actively seeking out fanfiction of themselves. How do you feel about mindcrackers lurking on here? Which mindcrackers that aren't so open about it do you think lurk on here. If you yourself reading this post somehow find yourself to be a lurking mindcracker, are you willing to make an account or an anonymous post with maybe a vague tweet or something to show that you are in fact lurking and not a figment of our imaginations? What do you think makes the mindcrackers want to read the salad? If you are a mindcracker, feel free to tell us. I wonder if they do it because it's amusing like a good joke or a bad pun, do they do it merely out of curiosity, or do they merely enjoy fanfiction in the same way that many of us do - as an exploration of people we know and like doing interesting and adventurous things in a fictitious setting that they don't normally do?We don't need to mention the smut but you can if you want.
Lots of questiony thing and stuff to talk about here today. Anyways, enjoy your SundayI :D
Alpaca.
Pause read fanficton on stream!!! And it wasn't even on Salad. Apparently there's fic on wattpad. It's official. The kinky people hang out on wattpad.
More like saturday chat but by the time you see this it'll probs be sunday in some part of the globe. give this 10 mins for nz at least. But who even cares I'm the one who posts this thing and
Not really gonna talk about events in salad or Mindcrack today. Instead, I've got some more general and even a couple of meta things to talk about. So here we go. (Also, happy b-day, Kurt!)
Let's start with the short and sweet stuff. I just want to start off by saying congrats to some of the members who joined between the 150 and 200 member mark as reading some of their fics, I'm starting to see a good amount of improvement in fic quality from people such as
Still on the short side, just a reminder that people properly tag posts. If it's fiction, use the fanficton tag, if it's something else, look in that tag to see what kind of things are posted to that tag before adding that tag. Make sure that when you add the tag, it's spelled and worded exactly as in the sidebar otherwise it won't be added. And on correct tag usage, when tagging Mindcrackers, don't go overboard with the tags. The tags are used to find fics about those people, not people who have a one sentence mention. I recommend keeping it to the main characters in that fic. And if you want to be super helpful with the SFP, no more than 4 character tags. Tagging is good, but don't go overboard. Also make sure you're appropriately adding age-restriction barriers such as nsfw and 18+ where appropriate.
More on the short things, in a recent livestream Seth mentioned that he has recorded sans pants before. Other Mindcrackers have also mentioned this in the past. What are your thoughts on this? Any prompty fic ideas come out of it?
In the recent podcast the salad, or more specifically, the mindcrack fanfic site was brought up with promises of linking Sevadus to it after the podcast. As of late, Vechs has also made plenty of salad mentions, and t has been talked about by various mindcrackers a lot more than it used to be. This got me thinking and I wanted to talk about it here.
What do you guys think about the more common mentions of salad by mindcrackers? To some extent they're good in directing more members towards mindcrack fanficton which can be good, but making a bit of a name for ourselves does have other connotations. TBH, some part of me is a little uncomfortable about the salad mentions, especially from people like Vechs who seem to mention it at least every other week or more as of late. I feel like some of that taboo about real person fiction and the main unspoken rule about not showing them the rpf fic is being impeded on and I also kind of wonder what kind of audience those mentions are bringing to salad and wonder if all these mentions may soon start to direct trolls in out direction. It is great that mindcrack is generally so accepting of fanfiction and in some cases, openly encourages it which is a luxury many other fandoms don't have, but I kinda feel like salad is the kind of thing better kept hush-hush about - more of a question whispered between strangers in the dark or exchanged under the quiet of private message. Do you think salad should be openly mentioned? How do hearing those mentions make you feel?
And a continuation of this? At's now becoming more known that mindcrackers and such still read some of the fics on here with some of them such as Aurey and Vechs actively seeking out fanfiction of themselves. How do you feel about mindcrackers lurking on here? Which mindcrackers that aren't so open about it do you think lurk on here. If you yourself reading this post somehow find yourself to be a lurking mindcracker, are you willing to make an account or an anonymous post with maybe a vague tweet or something to show that you are in fact lurking and not a figment of our imaginations? What do you think makes the mindcrackers want to read the salad? If you are a mindcracker, feel free to tell us. I wonder if they do it because it's amusing like a good joke or a bad pun, do they do it merely out of curiosity, or do they merely enjoy fanfiction in the same way that many of us do - as an exploration of people we know and like doing interesting and adventurous things in a fictitious setting that they don't normally do?
Alpaca.
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 11:56 am (UTC)Also, yes, Mindcrackers recording without pants is great.
(Shhh it's 7AM here and I haven't slept yet.)
(Snacking with SunsetMondays, just a spoon away from happiness!)
Alpaca.
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 12:11 pm (UTC)It was a nice surprise to find out that Kurt's birthday was a day before mine.
I find it cool that the 'Crackers are taking more of an interest to this little community
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 02:12 pm (UTC)On that note, it appears that while the original posters can add tags, they cannot remove them. That will still require mod intervention to fix. D:
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 02:41 pm (UTC)maybe it's fine for the people who write mainly fluff fics, but, being a mainly smut writer myself, it's making me far more hesitant to post works.
well not completely. i've been pretty busy as of late, though i've been writing on tumblr. im doing this nsfw challenge, which i was planning on posting in three separate parts.
but still, it's kind of at a grey area at the moment. do i ignore the fact that people who may not be totally accepting and post work, or do i take that into consideration and save the weird stuff for my tumblr?
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 04:30 pm (UTC)We are in a gray zone of "what is propper when writing FanFictions", and as such I follow the Secret Tree House guildelines: "They are aware that we exist. We don't bring the topic to them, but if they want to talk about it, it is their fair right to do so."
What does irk me about it a little is the fact that we are talkebd about not as "the FanFiction site" but as "the shippy FanFiction site" and the fact that, whenever it is brought up, those are the stories that are talked about.
I understand that this is part of what we are. Hell, it is a HUGE part of what we are and it is great the way it is! - But we are more then just that.
I can proudly say "I am a member of the Salad", because we are a great cummunity of many thinghs, of many ideas and various levels of quality in writing.
We are the part of the Mindcrack fan community that writes about what we love instead of making videos or drawings (Not that we don't do that, because we do that too, but it is not something that is done as much here as that we post that elsewhere.)
In short: I don't mind if we are brought up, but I would like to be seen as what we are, and not as what we appear to be at first glance.
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 04:32 pm (UTC)I just joined here mainly because the mindcrackers were mentioning the salad. So I don't mind, but I can see other people minding them mentioning it so much.
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 05:14 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 05:25 pm (UTC)the community on reddit...not as nice to us...
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 05:28 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 06:02 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 06:42 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 07:35 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 07:37 pm (UTC)Then again, I just like talking about stuff.
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 08:02 pm (UTC)I don't mind salad being mentioned really. It brings more people who will add to our great community. My only worry is that someone will come along with less.... kind... intent. But I figure that when that does happen, we can deal with it.
Oh and question for my own fic! I'm writing Aureylian in as my main character but I haven't been subbed to her for very long so i don't know a lot of things about her (or her pets in this case). I've writen that she has her own horse and I need a name for it, but I don't know if she already has a horse in minecraft with a name that I can use. She also has a dog but again, same problem. So I was wondering if anyone knows if Aurey has a named horse and dog. I need to know so I can either use existing names or make them up. Thanks! :)
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 08:19 pm (UTC)(Also, I'll keep the "tagging too many Mindcrackers" thing in mind for future fics. :b)
And welcome welcome to anyone new who's reading this that I didn't get a chance to welcome before!
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 08:20 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 08:21 pm (UTC)i go on there for the mindcrack sub, some of the more feminist subs, and askreddit (story time). that's it.
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 09:01 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Saturday, June 14th, 2014 09:04 pm (UTC)Alpaca?
no subject
Date: Sunday, June 15th, 2014 12:41 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Sunday, June 15th, 2014 12:46 am (UTC)On the plus side it's yay a couple of them may approve of the smut, but then there's fretting over if they see it more as something to have a good laugh over. And I guess the completely non-accepting mindcrackers tend to keep their distance.
Though I'm still definitely curious about why whenever it's mentioned to someone new in most cases, one of their first reactions is to ask for a link.
no subject
Date: Sunday, June 15th, 2014 01:02 am (UTC)Tagtagtagtag. I will be good about tags, I promise. :3
I don't really have an opinion on the talky bit. As far as I think, they can talk about whatever they like. I do worry about getting hateful people here, but rolling with the punches has always been my strategy for internet things. And besides, people have been pretty respectful so far. There's no reason why that can't continue. *shrug* Eh, I suppose I'm an eternal optimist.
no subject
Date: Sunday, June 15th, 2014 01:35 am (UTC)I have yet to watch the Podcast, but from reading this thread, it doesn't seemed like we've been mentioned in a bad light. Until that happens, I won't worry too much. :]
no subject
Date: Sunday, June 15th, 2014 01:41 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Sunday, June 15th, 2014 02:27 am (UTC)yeah, and i have my google docs folder which is dedicated to the things that'll never see the light of day. there are just some lines that i'm not willing to cross in the public eye.
it kinda gives me some hope that they don't immediately say "wtf ew" at the fanfictions. we are pretty respectful as a community, and not in their face about it...so i guess that's where some of that...not immediately disgusted mindset has come from.
no subject
Date: Sunday, June 15th, 2014 02:53 am (UTC)I am very proud of my involvement in the Salad, I've gone so far as to have a cute salad-bowl badge made just so I can have a private joke with some of my like-minded friends :3
no subject
Date: Sunday, June 15th, 2014 03:10 am (UTC)I'm going to go bug Tsu about what Alpaca means...
no subject
Date: Sunday, June 15th, 2014 08:47 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Sunday, June 15th, 2014 08:55 am (UTC)Here, have a link. (Warning for very nsfw) http://www.wattpad.com/10969423-a-night-on-mindcrack
no subject
Date: Sunday, June 15th, 2014 10:35 am (UTC)no subject
Date: Monday, June 16th, 2014 04:22 am (UTC)~ajrainbowz
no subject
Date: Monday, June 16th, 2014 06:55 pm (UTC)(also, do you know about what time in the stream he started reading that?)
no subject
Date: Tuesday, June 17th, 2014 12:41 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Tuesday, June 17th, 2014 12:43 pm (UTC)Wait wait wait. Been scrolling through the stream for the past 45 mins with crappy aus i-net being a pain and not loading all too quickly. But alas, I found it. 2:29:10 would be a good place to start watching.
no subject
Date: Tuesday, June 17th, 2014 12:44 pm (UTC)/alpaca/
no subject
Date: Tuesday, June 17th, 2014 12:45 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Tuesday, June 17th, 2014 06:30 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Tuesday, June 17th, 2014 08:24 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Tuesday, June 17th, 2014 09:46 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Wednesday, June 18th, 2014 08:18 am (UTC)Either way, I also feel that shipping should be a bit more organic than having a person almost constantly ask to be shipped or ask for fics of a pairing involving them. If you're asking for people to ship you with someone like that and forcing the flirting so much it just feels plastic and unpleasant.
no subject
Date: Wednesday, June 18th, 2014 08:25 am (UTC)I'm all for the attention, don't get me wrong, but we're a fanfic site. Fanfics of any kind should be acknowledged, regardless of whether the characters featured in it are banging each other.
no subject
Date: Wednesday, June 18th, 2014 12:43 pm (UTC)--A happy belated birthday to Mr. KurtJMac. Though you don’t drink anymore, I toast you with the finest scotch I could afford, sir. Let us hope people don’t mix up your birthdate again next year. *chuckle*
--Its rather gratifying being a veteran writer (and now a veteran Saladier) to watch the newcomers improve before our eyes. I only wish I could do more for the newcomers, but time and life’s circumstances are putting a serious damper on it.
--With all the new tags (I’m still trying to find time to put tags on everything I’ve submitted thus far, too) it’s no surprise that people have having trouble adjusting, especially the newcomers. It’ll be a habit we’ll all need to learn eventually if we’re going to make this site a bit less of a hassle to navigate. Might I suggest enforcing tags in some way? … hopefully something short of hiding the post altogether?
Now, the big topic.
On the whole, I am rather ambivalent to the whole ‘Salad being mentioned off-handedly/outright by the heroes that inspired it’ kerfuffle. All at once, it is good for us to get acknowledged and receive the traffic that said acknowledgement generates; yet I am uncertain about what sort of first impression are we giving the uninitiated coming to see what we’re really like and worrying that they will not like what they find. In the end, publicity is publicity, and whether we like it or not, we’re getting that attention… and the consequences generated thereof.
Brace yourselves. Change is coming.
I’ve long ago accepted that shipping was going to be a major part of the Salad’s identity, no matter how hard we try to downplay it. It was born from a desire to write fanfic of every sort--especially slashshippy--in a safe and accepting place far from the vitriol that threatened to dampen it. It is my hope that this open, vulnerable, and accommodating nature remains core to the Salad and that same nature evolves into something more as our beloved sub-community grows and inevitably attracts the same bad eggs that warranted the creation of the Salad in the first place.
That said (and I know you other veterans are tired of hearing/reading me harping on this) I do dream of the Salad being referred to as being more than ‘the shippy site’ and the fact that ‘it exists’. It could be the home of some of the best fanfics produced for the Mindcrackhead fandom, a place where aspiring writers can go to -learn- what it takes to write the next great fanfic, and where there is an impressive stable of veteran writers willing to teach those who come wanting to follow in their footsteps. Therefore, I do find it a bit of a shame and a bit heartbreaking that “oh, hey. XYZ told us we could find some hot ships here” is a thing, and that’s all the majority of newcomers are looking for/are willing to provide us with if they want to add content to our happy little page here.
I wish that weren’t an unwanted truth, but it is and I don’t think there’s really much we could do about it. A fellow Saladier and someone familiar with heavy shipping in fandoms observed that shipping tends to get the most attention the quickest and it tends to be remembered the most easily. Have to admit that I’m of the mind that the previous statement is because that is what the mainstream has been trained to expect out of our beloved artform of choice; and it doesn’t help that ‘hot ships and smut’ happen to be the stereotype people are quick to jump to when they hear the word ‘fanfiction’.
And with the way them younguns and a good hefty chunk of us folks who’ve lived at least more than twenty summers got their brains wired, there’s really no mass remedy mortals can cook up for that desire to see some rather twisted fantasies become manifest. Honestly and unfortunately (and I apologize for this opinion,) the ubiquitous shipfics the Salad (and sites like it) are (in)famous for are an analgesic balm for that one unfortunately permanent and nasty mental itch that won’t ever abate (if that makes any sense.) All we could ever hope to do is just play damage control, and I'm persuaded that’s a major part of why there was a major overhaul of the tagging system recently.
I’m sad to say that I’m also fairly certain that the insatiable desire to see “upper-end” shipping and the circlejerk that tends to follow in its wake has scared off some good folks that might have one day become the greatest advocates of this artform of adulation… and turned them into our most vocal opposition. When I heard news that Lady BlueBayou was absolutely terrified of/disgusted at us and what our pens and keyboards could conjure, it was everything I could do to keep myself from running to the rescue and looking more like the uneducated and uninformed dork I already was… and (as much as I hate to say this) I don’t think any amount of damage control, introduction, forewarning, and order is really going stem the tide of detractors nor will it assuage the fears of those who really don’t understand our medium and the motives behind our choices (and I really doubt anyone will be willing to set aside the time to understand, either. Stereotypes are easier to handle than understanding, unfortunately.)
And the breaking of this unfortunate stereotype that “fanfic = shippy” is why I even started writing Mindcrack-inspired fiction in the first place; a trend I hope others would perpetuate (To the few stellar writers who already do, I applaud you.) and that the lurking Mindcrackers would take note of and acknowledge in a positive light.
There is more to fanfic than seeing two people getting intimate and loveydovey (to the point of ‘crossing swords’) -- it can be about friends just being friends, family being family, heroes being heroes. Stories can be compelling without having the climax be one in the bedroom or the shower; character development can be more how one’s feelings for another develop into romance; relationships between characters can be more than between lovers, villains, and rivals; settings can transcend the server and even real life. The final products of fanfiction can be as polished and as thought-provoking as a store-bought hardcover novel and something beyond the usual stilted walls of text, spelling, and punctuation the circlejerkers characterise our artform as.
The Salad can be more and the stories we produce here can be more. It is my foolish hope that our patrons (be they the adoring fans and the actual Mindcrackers alike) and the fresh eyes that will follow them, will see and acknowledge the true versatility of our artform and come away enlightened as much as they were entertained. … and yes, I acknowledge that this is all easier said than done.
TL;DR and in closing--while I am pleased and excited to know more eyes are on us, it pains me to see that many of us are willingly and unwittingly (and some of us knowingly) perpetuating the stereotypes that have long been a stigma on our artform of choice. I can only hope that we will continue making bold steps toward not only improving our community page and content as our community evolves and grows exponentially, but also improving our presence in the larger Mindcrack community; that we will one day be remembered as more than ‘that one shippy site’ by our heroes and inspirations, but as that renegade sub-community that fostered some of the best writers and ship-centric/non-ship-centric fiction the Mindcrack community ever produced.
And that’s my few thousand bucks. Don’t spend it all in one place, folks. <3
~Lioness
no subject
Date: Wednesday, June 18th, 2014 02:15 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Thursday, June 19th, 2014 10:10 am (UTC)Though, may I propose changing the subheading thing to Mindcracklove: the largest community for Mindcrack fanfiction, both general fic and shipping alike.
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 21st, 2014 07:02 am (UTC)Ideas.
no subject
Date: Saturday, June 21st, 2014 02:57 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Saturday, June 21st, 2014 11:00 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: Saturday, June 21st, 2014 11:56 pm (UTC)Speaking of which...
Do we have an 'official' Salad logo? I was thinking that your icon could be it, if we don't have an official logo.